#WTF: Kevin's Kephalonomancy is Kontagious
Playing Hard To Get/Easy To Lose: Science Isn't A Fan (Part 2 - MONOGAMIZED!)
<editorsnote> Nerds, meet Kevin. I found him on craigslist, kinda like how I found that half eaten bag of pretzels, and last Friday's booty call. Casual encounters, FTW! He's hilarious, and smart ... and little elves dance in his footprints as he walks. For the record, I've made two of those facts up. </editorsnote>
#TalkNerdyToMeLover's Kevin Herman
[Part 1]
Once you’ve selected a main squeeze and changed your Facebook relationship status, ‘playing hard to get’ can do naught but shake its tiny fist and scurry off. When you’re actually in a committed relationship, it’s sort of by definition impossible to ‘play hard to get,’ but that doesn’t mean that the same principles can’t be applied.
‘Easy to Lose’ is the mustachioed, monogamous big brother of ‘Hard to Get.’ It’s the same basic strategy of stoking someone’s hots for you by implying the obstacle of real or imagined competition in your partner’s mind, except this iteration is retooled for those already in a relationship, giving not the impression that they need to work harder to earn your affection, but that they need to work harder to keep it; less emphasis on the concept of posing a challenge and more on just making them jealous as shit, but same overall idea.
And ironically, it suffers from the exact same gender-disparate pitfalls as playing hard to get. This is especially problematic as the strategy not only has a lot more riding on its success - the survival of an established relationship, not just a budding one - but also because it sees far more action in the field than its little brother.
As with ‘playing hard to get,’ guys have the luxury of a fairly proven success rate when it comes to levying jealousy as a weapon. Sure, both guys and girls will get a touch pissed once the game is afoot, but that’s where the sex-based response similarities end.
According to plenty o’ research, women have evolutionarily placed a premium on their interpersonal relationships - back in the good ol’ cave days, both their survival and emotional well-being more or less depended on it; these days it’s mostly the latter, but it’s no less important. This relationship-oriented mentality promotes the vigilant maintenance of one’s ties with friends, family, and one’s romantic partner; it’s also why women tend to notice and actively dwell on problems in a relationship whereas men take home the Olympic gold for ignoring the fuck out of them (subsequently expressing shock and surprise when they get dumped, despite the preponderance of problems that to everyone else had obviously been plaguing the relationship for a while). As such, when a dude makes a girl jealous by flirting around, data suggests that she will (yes, get a bit peeved, but then) instinctively assume that the current state of the relationship is the problem and constructively work to improve it, thereby removing the guy’s reason for straying and protecting the relationship itself from further peril. Whether he’d hinted at more sex or more doting being on his wish list, there’s a decent chance his manipulative ass will get just that.
And once again, women’s adoption of the tactic, according to experiments and surveys, seems to rest on the implicit and incredibly generous assumption that men are just as relationship-oriented and constructive as they are. Ha! That’s what you GET for giving us way too much credit!Evolutionarily, if it can be said that women treat the underlying problem in the face of jealousy, men seem to specifically just target the symptoms; boring relationship and ill treatment of your partner be damned - that asshole at the bar she’s flirting with is the real problem and you will crush him. Outside threats trump structural integrity on the “to do” list.
As such, when women deliberately try to make their men jealous by ramping up the harmless flirting, one of three things tend to happen, absolutely none of which resemble a ‘desirable outcome’:
1) Guy just either isn’t the jealous type, trusts you too much, or is totally oblivious and just doesn’t notice. This is more or less the opposite of what was supposed to happen, and common side effects include increased frustration, bruised self-esteem, and worst case - going from pretend flirting to real fucking around.
2) Guy notices. He notices so hard. He notices so hard that he...uh, grows sullen, retreats to the couch to watch TV, and broods by himself because he now feels shitty and just wants to be alone. Again, fail.
3) Guy definitely notices. He walks over with a vase filled with flowers and you think “Aha! It totally worked! He’s so hot and bothered over me!” right until he smashes the vase into the face of the guy you were flirting with and puts him in the hospital, thinking to himself that that’s the end of that. The worst part is that this does actually happen, and way more often than you’d hope. And in the worst cases, the asshole puts the girl in the hospital too.
Wrapping it up - yeah, the costs vs. benefits are not exactly the same for girls and guys.
The good news? It’s a shitty idea for anyone to play the jealousy card. Even though guys do come out on top in this round, any advantage conferred is incredibly short-term at best. The tactic does nothing to protect against, and really, just adds fuel to the inevitable long-term buildup of resentment a girl will feel after being manipulated in this fashion however many times. And hell hath no fury like a woman’s long-term buildup of resentment.
So, yes: It’s a lose-lose for everybody. If there’s a grotesque elephant in the room, don’t try to covertly assassinate it and hope no one notices - call attention to it and calmly discuss. Don’t play Cold War with your love life. Hash that shit out directly, constructively, and without criticism. The staggering amount of literature and lay-wisdom dedicated to offering every way but the direct way of dealing with relationship problems speaks volumes to how massively uncomfortable we are with simple, straightforward communication that may have consequences - but there’s also literature out there that can help you do that, do it well, and be happy.
#nerdsunite
For more of Kevin’s politically incorrect verbal incontinence, follow him on Twitter or check out his like, completely legitimate astrological operation at Fiehard.